The traditional approach to the teaching of carbocation chemistry deliberately seems to avoid discussing bonding, electron delocalisation, and even such practical concepts as isoenergetic hydride shifts.
The reality is that what is often presented in organic chemistry textbooks and in many organic chemistry courses is far from what has been established by the research of the past fifty years. Carbocations are NOT simply molecules with holes in them.
Introducing students to certain aspects of computational chemistry can help present students with a much clearer view of these intermediates.
There is no excuse for presenting misleading or erroneous concepts!
Back to Chemical Education (Contributed Papers)
Back to The 41st Midwest Regional Meeting (October 25-27 2006)